
It’s easy to blame poor Donald Trump for the current extremism of the Republican party from blah-blah-blah-we-hate-taxes to raped-10-year-olds-shouldn’t-have-abortions. The truth is that the roots of right-wing extremism can be traced back to the moment that early humans first realized that their environment was fraught with danger. “Things were better before poisonous snakes and Neanderthals and shit like that came along,” they complained to each other. “At least mammoths and giant elephants give us food. Snakes and Neanderthals just take, take, take and give nothing. How can we get rid of them?”
Hunter-gatherers required many square miles to find adequate roots, grubs, berries and whatever else it was that kept them alive. The last thing they wanted was to pen themselves in. The advent of agriculture created a need, for the first time in human history, for security to protect the crops that humans worked really hard to maintain. Walls were invented, and humans discovered the joy of looking out on their walled-in fields and yelling “Hey you SOBs out there! Don’t even think about coming close! I was here first and I will take you out! Go back where you came from!”
As small settlements gradually turned into the beginnings of empires, humans had to invent religion (“Hey, I didn’t make this shit up. God told me to do it.”) and slavery (“OK, so there are humans and something else that also has arms and legs. Let’s make them slaves.”) to manage people. Otherwise, everyone would be running amok and the pyramids would never have gotten built and people would have to kill each other using just their bare hands.
As civilizations became more sophisticated over the millennia, a relatively small group of humans found that they could sort of control a relatively huge group of humans, mostly by having a lot of laws that people couldn’t read. But that still left way more people who needed controlling than people who controlled. They found a solution. “The gods told us that women must serve men” effectively cut in half the number of people who needed controlling. The top guys only needed to control the men and the men controlled their women. Bingo, division of labor was born.
This entire system worked fairly well until the industrial revolution, when hands became passe and machines started to take over. In the US, to make matters worse, slavery was abolished, and nobody knew what to do with all the extra humans who were wandering around, demanding to be taught how to read. Public service organizations like the Ku Klux Klan were formed, to deal with this issue (“This country was created solely by white people. We know all the shit. Don’t even try.”)
As time passed, technology replaced religion for a lot of humans, and many black people managed, under the most extreme obstacles, to forget their assigned place in the pecking order and get advanced degrees. The white humans who were left behind were not happy (“Things were better before blacks came along. Why did they come here, anyway, and ruin our lives?” “We need religion back, real religion, meaning Christian religion, not fake religion.” “We need what created this great country: white men who could shoot straight at anything that moved and then go to church on Sunday.”)
The aftermath of World War II created a new demon for American humans to go after. (No, not Nazism or Hitler.) It was Communism, that thing that Russia invented to get back at all the rich people. The John Birch Society and The McCarthy trials railed against this new enemy and they had their moment in the sun. But they were short-lived. They failed at capturing the imagination of the American people.
Then, in the 1980s, humans re-discovered their power. Going after other countries was a waste of time. It was far more efficient to go after ourselves. Any number of people were ripe for the picking (“Blacks just want to watch TV all day and collect welfare.” “Jews control the liberal media.” “Gays and women who want abortions and people who follow any religion except Christianity are an abomination against God.” “People who hate guns aren’t patriots.” “All those people crossing the southern border either just want our jobs ((or no jobs at all))” “My taxes are going to support deadbeats.”).
Throughout time, humans have always been angry (“I hate those Neanderthals” “My boss is a dick.”) But now they discovered that their anger had been misplaced. Now they were given a target: all the groups identified above, as well as the liberal media, higher education, and Democrats. They started to have a field day with their anger. And one man (No, not Trump.) solved the pesky issue of truth: the great visionary, Roger Stone. He coined the phrase “Stop the steal” in 2016, even before Trump was elected. Stone knew that he had invented a phrase that could be used in just about any situation one desired. The website http://www.stopthesteal.org was registered, and history was made.
“Stop the Steal” was brilliant. It galvanized folks. It was a phrase that fit anything they were angry about. It was originally used against Ted Cruz’s win in the Iowa Caucus. (Yes, true.) It was locked, loaded and ready to blast away, should Hillary have won the 2020 presidential election. And it was used against Biden’s presidential win. The right wingers were on a roll.
The train of right-wing extremism continues to barrel on, its cars festooned with more American flags than Betsy Ross could have stitched in 100 lifetimes. Aside from that, it looks like any other train, except for the fact that it’s going backward at alarming speed, and there don’t seem to be any brakes on it. Beneath its wheels are crushed whatever and whoever tries to get in its way. Some believe that it hurtles backward toward a future none of us could have imagined. Still others are convinced that the train will shortly run out of steam. The rest focus solely on what’s available in the dining car. The train doesn’t care. It just keeps moving.
Shelley
July 19, 2022
I think you have what could be a best selling elementary school history text book. Why not? We need SOMETHING to counteract the crazy shit the religious right wants to (indoctrinate) teach our kids.
Sent from my iPhone
Life in the Boomer Lane
July 22, 2022
I would love to write an elementary school history book. And, during my book launch party, I would especially enjoy being attacked by most of the same good folks who overran the capitol.
Keith
July 19, 2022
Renee, well-reputed historian Jon Meacham penned a terrific must read called “The Soul of America,” where he defines we have always had a struggle to overcome our worst instincts. There have been moments where we finally got it right, but sometimes it took time. I highly recommend this book to your readers. There is even a documentary on this book as he travels the country.
McCarthyism was a dark period in our country that continued too long as McCarthy was a demagogue. It took a highly reputed newsperson named Edward R. Murrow and a lawyer for the US Army named Joseph Welch to show what an absolute tyrant McCarthy was. Welch’s line asked of McCarthy which is oft-quoted is “Have you no sense of decency?”
At one point in the early 1930s, we had over 25% of our Senators and 100 Congressmen with ties to the KKK. This is highly troubling. This is a reason Jim Crow lasted so long, as too many were complicit in making it continue.
I point these two examples out as they are not unlike what we are seeing now with the extremists who have been catered to by the Republican party. Conservative pundit Michael Gerson said the “Republican party is in decay.” I agree. A party cannot vilify its truth tellers and aggrandize its liars and maintain gravitas and veritas. Names like Trump, Jordan, Meadows, Giuliani, Eastman, Bannon, Stone, etc. will be remembered in the same category as Senator McCarthy.
Keith
Thanks for writing this. Keith
Life in the Boomer Lane
July 22, 2022
Keith, I had absolutely no idea that such a large percentage of our elected reps were members of the KKK. Makes me surprised that there has been any movement at all in human rights in this country. We have such an abysmal track record.
Keith
July 23, 2022
Renee, that one surprised me as well. Meacham’s book and documentary are excellent. He shows that we have had to overcome our worst extincts, which is when we shined. The Civil Rights and Voting Rights laws are keen examples. The Watergate hearings and the current House Select Committee are good examples of standing up for our constitutional rights against a corrupt leader. Keith
Life in the Boomer Lane
July 23, 2022
Agreed!
Widdershins
July 20, 2022
Yep, that about covers it. 😦
Life in the Boomer Lane
July 22, 2022
Unfortunately, right?
erminerose
July 20, 2022
Well done, LBL. The last paragraph is fabulous. Thanks for your insightful observations, friend!
Life in the Boomer Lane
July 22, 2022
And thanks for reading. Everyday, I sink more and more into a belief that this country is doomed, on many levels. Added to that is the latest poll on climate change. 1% of Americans believe that climate change is our number 1 problem. Looking just at young people, the percent goes up to 3. We have an astonishing ability to focus on everything that doesn’t matter, while the future is chomping at the ground we stand on.
David
July 27, 2022
I really like the paragraph on the sophistication of the men controlling the women now the reason for Abortion laws since the men can’t or don’t control women as much as in the past… the real threat toward the fascist Right…
Since women have periods and get pregnant (something women can’t seem to get away from) it became obvious this is an easy way to legislate oppressive control…
As LBL noted dividing the problem works: get control of the women and the men will follow…
Eventually, the facsist Right will legislate all opposing parties out of existence.
Then, all-is-well once there is only one-party-rule…
Life in the Boomer Lane
July 28, 2022
Thanks, David. Yes: one gender, one party, one religion, one source of authority. Sounds familiar.